Workshop review
By Hans-Peter Schelian, owner of Schelian IT Consulting
We took a transport planning system that has grown for more than 20 years and brought it up to date in three weeks. Without AI, we would have planned two developers for nine months. The new versions have been delivered and are in use.
Numbers like these can easily sound like marketing. So this article sets out what was measured, what was estimated and who did what.
The starting point
The system grew across several generations of technology: from .NET Framework 4 through .NET Core 2 and .NET 6 to .NET 8. It consists of 92 projects with around 800,000 lines of code, plus a generated data access layer.
Anyone who knows a system like this knows that every generation leaves its own quirks behind. A modernisation touches almost every corner, and in every corner there is someone who works with it daily.
Tests first, then the rebuild
Before we changed a single line, we covered the existing behaviour almost completely with automated tests. The tests record what the software does today.
That was the most important step of the whole project. It is what made it possible to check after every step that everything still worked as before. And it is what allowed the agents to work on their own, without a person having to follow every change line by line.
What the agents did
Coding agents brought the application and security technology up to date. The software now runs on .NET 10.
Agents also operated the software through the screen and the browser, the way a user would. They entered data and checked the results from start to finish.
What the human did
It did not work without people. One developer guided the modernisation for around 60 hours: writing instructions for the agents, reviewing results and testing by hand.
Responsibility for every version we deliver stays with us.
How to read the numbers
The three weeks are measured calendar time. During those three weeks the agents worked on all seven days, including evenings and nights.
The nine months are our estimate for the same modernisation without AI: two developers, five days a week, around ten hours a day. That comes to around 3,900 working hours.
For cost, the second comparison is the one that counts: around 60 hours of human work against an estimated 3,900.
What I take away from it
Companies running specialist software that has grown over the years often put off modernising it for years. The reason has almost always been the effort. That reason is now going away.
What remains is the precondition: today's behaviour has to be testable. Without tests, the agents would have worked just as fast, but nobody would have known whether the result was right.
I wrote my first software in 1989, for my own business. I have not seen a leap like this since.